a loving rebuke to the modern church and her leaders

Photo by Sarau00ed Carrasco on Pexels.com

A friend of mine recently shared a clip on Facebook of a pastor lamenting the consumeristic approach that most Christians take to the modern church.

This is true.

The “consumer” church model is horrible. It allows really shallow and immature Christians to stay shallow and immature.

But here’s the bigger issue at hand that he failed to address.

99% of what churches are doing needs to stop. The endless programs. They need to stop.

People are substituting actual spiritual life in Jesus Christ, fellowship with the Holy Spirit and each other with “I serve on the blank team.”

These programs are that “form of Godliness” that denies the “power thereof”.

These programs are largely the fruit of church leadership that has lost it’s way and is not doing what the Lord called them to do, which is to “shepherd the sheep”.

The way we shepherd the sheep is by leading them to The Shepherd, Jesus. We do this by knowing them intimately.

It’s not possible to know more than say a dozen or so people intimately because intimacy requires time and proximity and there are only so many hours in a day and days in a week.

Jesus had many disciples, but only 12 were at the Last Supper. And even among those he had 3 that were with him in the Garden.

There’s a reason for that. God was showing us something.

There is a fellowship that God desires for us to have with him and one another. This is the fellowship that the Father, Son and Spirit have always had with each other and that God has now invited us into.

But it’s small. It’s close. It’s constant.

Marriage and the family unit is the best example of what the church actually is and should look like. This is where intimacy takes place and where “love covers a multitude of sins.”

The current church model simply can’t replicate this.

It’s not possible for 3 or 4 elders to truly know 100 plus sheep.

Yet among the elders there is a constant pursuit of more sheep to shepherd.

Why?

We don’t truly shepherd the sheep we have now. Why are we looking for more?

Why do we have more and more and more endless programs and outreach? Why do our churches continue to grow bigger and bigger and bigger?

The “bigger” seems to be the constant pursuit. It is always used to claim “God is really at work here!” or “God is really doing something in this place.”

But I’m not sure he is.

People keep coming and they move from one building to the next, one church to another, they’re looking for Jesus and fellowship with one another. They’re told, “sign up for the such and such team”. But when they come and go every Sunday, they see the same faces, they say the same five second hellos and goodbyes. In the rare instance they share a burden and seek some level of intimacy beyond the trite shop talk that normally takes place those around them are looking for the exit.

There is this constant theme that “by our many good works do we show that we love Jesus” but when the real work of love is needed so few are willing to “bear one another’s burdens”.

Bearing the burdens of your brother is the true demonstration of love. “They will know you by your love for one another.” And bearing burdens takes intimacy. You’d actually have to know the man next to you to know what burdens he’s got. And to know someone takes time and proximity. It takes a willingness to enter into the suffering of another person.

But here’s the reality. Most people, most Christians, most churches, aren’t really interested in doing this.

They have their programs.

Instead of actually getting to know the people around them. Being transparent and doing the hard work of long phone calls, lunches, dinners, just general relationships, they’d rather keep things at an arms length. And the programs let them do that. They get the veneer of service to God and loving people without actually having to climb into the foxhole with anyone.

And it’s really and truly the leadership of these churches that is modeling this behavior for the churches.

Grow the church seems to be the only goal.

Grow the numbers. Grow the tithers. Build the building. Make it bigger. Add amenities.

But the simple command of “love one another” is being neglected.

The elders don’t know their sheep. Or maybe they know a handful and them and it stops there. Why? Well because again there’s only so many hours in a day, days in a week. It’s only possible to truly “know” so many people.

So why then is there this constant growth strategy at work? To add sheep to their flock that they can’t possibly attend to?

Why aren’t churches that move past say 12 families breaking into new fellowships and appointing new leaders to shepherd them?

Well I think the problem is probably money.

The modern church has turned into a business model.

It’s a model that we just don’t see in Scripture either.

The money of tithes and offerings is needed. They have to grow. Much like a bureaucracy that exists to perpetuate itself, increase its own staff and its paid “professionals”, the churches grow so that they can fund the salaries of the professionals, the buildings, the amenities and thereby attract more new sheep that can’t possibly be shepherded well.

So true discipleship isn’t happening.

The commands “love one another” and “feed my sheep” is being lost in the growth. Then it’s being substituted with “did you sign up for the such and such ministry…”

This just doesn’t work.

Well I guess it works for some. Those are okay with “the form of Godliness” but aren’t interested in the “power thereof…” And it’s the cross at work in their lives that is this “power thereof”. It’s the willingness to suffer for lovesake that’s the power thereof. It’s the willingness to know and love one another intimately that they’re not really interested in.

But I don’t think this is what Jesus intended for his church. I don’t think it’s what he’s building. I think it’s what men are building “for Jesus” and I’m not sure it’s actually for Him…

So if we lament the state of the “consumerist church” (and we should), well then, dear elder…

stop building them.

Stop modeling this for them.

Model for them actual shepherding. Actual love. In order to do this you’ll have to be committed to smaller, not bigger. To less breath and more depth.

And you know as well as I do… that model won’t fund a salary.

But that’s okay. There are jobs outside of being a professional minister. It’s possible to do both. All the apostles were bivocational. You can do that too. Paul had tent making. Peter was a fisherman.

But all of this would require a radical departure from the current status quo.

The leaders in the Lord’s church would have to set down a lot of idols. A lot of their own prerogatives and their own agendas.

They’d have to be willing to serve the Lord in simplicity as they love and shepherd his sheep.

I’m not sure the leadership of the modern church is ready to model that sacrifice for the church. Some are perhaps. Others are still seeking to “grow their ministry…”

And so we’ll keep on getting what we’ve got I guess.

A bunch of consumer Christians just following out the model that’s been created for them by their leaders. And then leaders upset that the consumers they sold their “church” to are treating it like it’s one of many on a shelf to choose from, to take from.

The answer to all this is the same as it has always been.

Repent.

But it starts at the top.

It would require a huge act of humility and contrition from these leaders. They’d have to model what confession of sin and repentance actually looks like.

There are men like Francis Chan that have done it. And still other nameless and faceless non “celebrity” Christians that have walked away from this whole thing we call “church” to seek Jesus and what he himself is building.

But they are few and far between.

I pray that they will grow in number.

The days are growing dark.

The sheep are scattered. They are lonely and afraid. They need shepherds that will point them to their Shepherd, even carry them to His feet if need be.

But if they chose to do this, to carry the sheep to their Shepherd… they’ll have to set down their idols first.

Unknown's avatar

About R Kyle McDaniel

Hey there! My name is Kyle McDaniel, I’m 39 years old and I live in Fort Worth, TX with my wife Kitty and our two kids, Henry 3 and Catherine 1. Both Kitty and I are “from” North Texas but have moved around here and there throughout our lives but this area has always felt like it was home for us. 1/7/2021: I figured it was time for an update. The four of us became the five of us this year as we welcomed our third child to our family, our precious baby girl Vivienne Coers McDaniel. Vivivenne means “alive” and Coers was my wife Kitty’s maiden name and it’s French meaning “heart/s” and it’s our faith the Lord will one day give her a new and living heart to fulfill the meaning of her name. Kitty and I met in December of 2010 and were married on July 28th, 2012. We had both come to know the Lord and be born again before meeting each other and have seen our relationship with Him grow and mature through the years of our marriage as we’ve learned to love each other as He has loved us. We are just a regular family I guess, just people who really need Jesus and love him very much. If you feel lead to reach out, please do so, we’d love to hear from you or anything you think the Holy Spirit would have you share with us. God Bless, Kyle
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply